Forecasting of the Traffic Situation in the Hannover Region
The main requirement of road traffic participants is to know the current traffic situation. Such data is typically obtained from routing services where the time of many different individual trips is taken into account.
In the context of Data4UrbanMobility tools were developed that allow to predict the traffic situation based on such time series data. The following figure presents an interface to visualize typical time series patterns as well as outliers present in the data:
The prediction of the traffic situation is made available in the form of a map based interface for the end user:
Data4UrbanMobility Data Protection Regulation
The work on the Data4UrbanMobility data protection regulation is completed. The document is publicly available and can be found here.
First Version of MiC-App Available
A first version of the novel MiC-App (Move in the City) App is now available for D4UM-associates as well as a protected group of public users. The mobile MiC-App is a tool to gather data.
MiC was developed by the Institute for Sustainable Urbanism at the University of Braunschweig and the Projektionisten GmbH. MiC links the growing awareness of digital citizen rights with the potential of evaluation big datasets. Therefore MiC gives the opportunity to citizen to actively participate in a citizen science project to take part in the development of the mobility of the feature.
MiC gathers data of the users movement, where the user has the about which data should be recorded. All data is pseudonymised such that the privacy of the contributing citizen is ensured.
Current Status:
In the first version of the app, the user can easily start and end the tracking of his/her movement. It is worth to point out, that the user decides when he is tracked and when not. A summary of his/her activity is available for the user as well as the opportunity to issue feedback or even delete all of his contributed data.
Updated System with Dashboard V2
With the new version of our system, the dashboard will provide even more insights into the impact of public events on the traffic situation.
The coloring and labels let us easily distinguish between the different type of events. By clicking on the label we show the typically affected subgraph for that event type. This allows the user to check what specific routes are typically affected by an event at that location.
Examples: Visualisation of a concert and a football game.
In addition, the graph at the top right gives additional information on how big the impact around the events start time tends to be.
{API}
We enriched the api endpoints with additional information from the data models that were developed as part of the research efforts.
D4UM App Version 1.0
We just released the first Version of the D4UM App. Every project member now has access to the application and can try out its features. Let’s quickly go over some of its main features.
The EFA integration (EFA is a routing engine covering Lower Saxony and Bremen ) allows for quick access to tip information using all available public transport options. Our focus, when designing the application, was on quick and easy navigation to provide a simple and easy to use trip planning tool.
Departures and Connections
On the departure screen we show the user the closes stops for public transportation in his immediate vicinity. On the connection screen the user can fill in his desired starting location( either an address or an existing stop ) and destination and query for what connections are available to him. The provided information contains real time data , meaning we are able to visualized delays for any given connection.
Map
On the map screen you can see and or find all available stops of public transportation. This allows for providing the user with a great way to find out what stops are available in their city. By clicking on any of the shown stops will open the departure screen and provide you with the information mentioned above. To better visualize a selected connection, we show the route you plan to travel on the map.
Menu / Settings
Additional features can be found in the settings menu of the application. Here you can find settings that allow you to customize your routing results for both the departures and connection screen. The best way to let us know what you think about the application is to use the feedback module. This can be found here as well. First click on the emoji that best describe how you feel about the app. And then put in any additional information or ideas or thoughts you may have. Now what is left is just to press send and you will send us an email.
We look forward to hearing from you.
Quantification and Prediction of Impact of Public Events
Current Data4UrbanMobility research results allow for measuring and prediction of spatial impact on road traffic of public events. Connected, affected street segments nearby public events are identified to measure the spatial impact. The approach is depicted in the following figure:
(Karte von https://www.openstreetmap.org)
An event is marked as yellow dot, affected streets in red and the measured impact in dark blue. Moreover, an approach making use of machine learning algorithms was developed to predict the impact determined in this way, resulting an error-reduction of up to 40% when compared to existing state-of-the-art approaches.
D4UM – Platform V1 Released
The first version of the Data4UrbanMobiltiy platform has been released. The platform was designed and implemented following a 3-tier-architecture. The platform provides RESTfull Web services for mobility applications like dashboards or mobile apps. As a demonstration, an interactive map application has been developed that visualizes the spatial impact of public events. The following figure shows a screenshot of the application.
The figure shows 4 public events in the city of Hannover. The colors represent different types of public events (e.g. concerts, fairs, sport events). The circles visualize the spatial impact on road traffic caused by the public events.
Comprehensive Set of Requirements
The Data4UrbanMobility analysis of requirements includes requirements of the application partners Region Hannover (RH) and Wolfsburg AG (WAG) as well as non functional requirements. The requirements were collected by MOMA. The L3S derived research question for data analysis which are based on the requirements of RH and WAG. The research question address especially the information needs of end-users.
The current research questions particularly include
- Automated verification of traffic warnings and prediction of their impact
- Identification of events and prediction of their impact
- Investigation of correlation of road traffic data, public transportation query logs, traffic warnings and twitterfeeds
- Determination of optimal traveling timepoints
Growing Data Collection
ISU create a comprehensive data matrix containing potential source of mobility related data. The Data4UrbanMobility data model describes all project relevant data sets and sets them into context. This makes the data available in a unified manor for both analysis and applications. The selected data sources were transformed according to the Data4UrbanMobility data model by L3S. The data quality of selected data sources (i.e. public transportation query logs and road traffic data) was examined.
Tools for extracting the relevant information from the datasets were developed to enable the integration of the datasets.
- Street and graph extraction from OpenStreetMap
- Bulkloader for public transportation queries
- Integration of “Zentrales Haltestellen Verzeichniss” (central registry of public transportation stops)
The current collection (December 12th 2017) contians
EFA-Logs: 17 million public transportation queries
Road traffic data: 174 thousand street sements with a frequency of 15 minutes
GTFS-data: 90 thousand. public transportation stops, 2.6 thousand routes
Weather: Radolan “Regenraster” (rain grid)
Twitter: 2,5 Mio. Tweets starting at June 2017
OSM: 440 thousand streets
Events: 21 thousand public events (August 14th 2016-July 17th 2018)
Traffic warnings: 13 thousand warning (since June 2017)
Visualization of Public Transportation Information
In order to allow intuitive analytics of public transportation information, the PROJEKTIONISTEN (PROJ) developed a dashboard web application. First prototypes visualize queries addressed to the regional timetable information system EFA (www.efa.de). The prototypes serve as foundations for exploration analyses as well as the implementation of future versions of the dashboard. The following figure shows an integrated visualization of the most frequent origins and destinations of the queries.
Analysen der EFA-Logs
Analysis of EFA Public Transportation Query Logs
Analyses regarding the impact of public events on public transportation are currently conducted to address early research questions. To this extend, explorative data analyses of the impact of major public events such as football games and medium sized events such as concerts were conducted. Visual analytics were used as a first step towards comprehensive analyses, which show start-like patterns for city center which identify mobility hubs of central importance.
The figure shows the direct connection between origin and destination of public transportation queries. Darker colors correspond to more frequent queried trips. Star-like pattern identify the central train station and the central metro station.
Analyses of single stations reveal weekday dependent patterns.
The figure depicts the average number of queries with the destination “Hannover Stadionbrücke”. Differences emerge between Weekends and workdays.
The impact of public events on the queries can be visualized as well.
The figure shows the number of queries with the Destination “Hannover Stadionbrücke” for Wednesday, April 26th 2017 (orange) as well as the average number of queries on a Wednesday for the same destination. On this day a concert took place in venue nearby. The concert start at 8 pm. The significant deviations between 5 pm and 7 pm is highly likely to be caused by visitors of the concert. This shows that public transportation queries are a valuable information source to investigate the impact of public events on mobility infrastructure.
- Hair Transplant Innovations: What’s New in the Industry. Grow, Hair Free Hair (2024).
- Exploring the Real-Time Capability of Electrical Impedance Tomography for Hand Sign Recognition in Robotic Hand Control. Ghoul, Bilel; Atitallah, Bilel Ben; Barioul, Rim; Fakhfakh, Ahmed; Kanoun, Olfa (2024). 1–6.
- Automatic Data Curation for Self-Supervised Learning: A Clustering-Based Approach. Vo, Huy V.; Khalidov, Vasil; Darcet, Timothée; Moutakanni, Théo; Smetanin, Nikita; Szafraniec, Marc; Touvron, Hugo; Couprie, Camille; Oquab, Maxime; Joulin, Armand; Jégou, Hervé; Labatut, Patrick; Bojanowski, Piotr (2024).
- Non-Deterministic and Risk Based Security Services. Doddi, Srinivas Rao; Kotamraju, Akshay Krishna (2024). 22(1) 307–310.
- A pair of possible supernovae Refsdal in the Pantheon+ sample. Sanejouand, Yves-Henri (2024).
- A pair of possible supernovae Refsdal in the Pantheon+ sample. Sanejouand, Yves-Henri (2024).
- A Brain-Inspired Model of Reaching and Adaptation on the iCub Robot. Fietzek, Torsten; Ruff, Christoph; Hamker, Fred H. (2024).
- Optimal feature subset deduction based on possibilistic feature quality classification and feature complementarity. Medhioub, Mouna; Bouhamed, Sonda Ammar; Kallel, Imene Khanfir; Derbel, Nabil; Kanoun, Olfa (2024). 249 123353.
- Digital Trace Data. Jungherr, Andreas (2024).
- Comparative Study of Data Reduction Methods in Electrical Impedance Tomography For Hand Sign Recognition. Ghoul, Bilel; Atitallah, Bilel Ben; Sahnoun, Salwa; Fakhfakh, Ahmed; Kanoun, Olfa (2024). (Vol. 1) 654–658.
- Investigation of Implicit and Contextual Cues for the Facilitation of Cooperative Automated Driving: A Qualitative Analysis. Dettmann, Andre; Berkemeier, Adelina; Felbel, Konstantin; Bullinger, Angelika C. (2024). 319–326.
- EDGE: Evaluation Framework for Logical vs. Subgraph Explanations for Node Classifiers on Knowledge Graphs. Sapkota, Rupesh; Köhler, Dominik; Heindorf, Stefan (2024).
- Comparative Study of sEMG Feature Evaluation Methods Based on the Hand Gesture Classification Performance. Hellara, Hiba; Barioul, Rim; Sahnoun, Salwa; Fakhfakh, Ahmed; Kanoun, Olfa (2024). 24(11)
- Unveiling the invisible: receivers use object weight cues for grip force planning in handover actions. Kopnarski, L.; Rudisch, J.; Kutz, D. F.; Voelcker-Rehage, C. (2024). 242(5) 1191–1202.
- eSim Guernsey. HolidayeSim (Nusal, ed.) (2024).
- Smoothing Out Smart Tech’s Rough Edges: Imperfect Automation and the Human Fix. Katzenbach, Christian; Pentzold, Christian; Viejo Otero, Paloma (2024). 7 23–43.
- Variable transformations in combination with wavelets and ANOVA for high-dimensional approximation. Potts, Daniel; Weidensager, Laura (2024). 50 53.
- Ultra-Fast Edge Computing Approach for Hand Gesture Classification Based on EIT Measurements. Mnif, Mahdi; Sahnoun, Salwa; Kaaniche, Marouene; Atitallah, Bilel Ben; Fakhfakh, Ahmed; Kanoun, Olfa (2024). 1–7.
- Flexible Oxide Electronics for Extreme Geometries and Mechanical Deformations. Münzenrieder, Niko; De Souza Oliveira, Hugo; Catania, Federica; Khaanghah, Niloofar Saeedzadeh; Lanthaler, Albert Heinrich; Corsino, Dianne; Cantarella, Giuseppe (2024). 08–11.
- Leading Manufacturer of High-Quality Coir Sheets | WeCoir. WeCoir (WeCoir, ed.) (2024).
- Computing Repairs Under Functional and Inclusion Dependencies via Argumentation. Mahmood, Yasir; Virtema, Jonni; Barlag, Timon; Ngomo, Axel-Cyrille Ngonga (2024).
- Real Time Parameter Estimation for Adaptive OFDM/OTFS Selection. Darghouthi, Amina (2024). 16(4)
- TripoSR: Fast 3D Object Reconstruction from a Single Image. Tochilkin, Dmitry; Pankratz, David; Liu, Zexiang; Huang, Zixuan; Letts, Adam; Li, Yangguang; Liang, Ding; Laforte, Christian; Jampani, Varun; Cao, Yan-Pei (2024).
- The Role of Sea-ice Insulation Effects on the Probability of AMOC Transitions. van Westen, René M.; Jacques-Dumas, Valérian; Boot, Amber A.; Dijkstra, Henk A. (2024).
- The Ladder of Data Citizen Participation: A Sociotechnical Lens for Designing Democratic Digital Services in the Data Economy. Horn, Viktoria; Draude, Claude (2024).
- The Ladder of Data Citizen Participation: A Sociotechnical Lens for Designing Democratic Digital Services in the Data Economy. Horn, Viktoria; Draude, Claude (2024).
- VFusion3D: Learning Scalable 3D Generative Models from Video Diffusion Models. Han, Junlin; Kokkinos, Filippos; Torr, Philip (2024).
- Pair coalescence times of ancestral lineages of two-dimensional logistic branching random walks. Birkner, Matthias; Depperschmidt, Andrej; Schlüter, Timo (2024).
- The Ladder of Data Citizen Participation: A Sociotechnical Lens for Designing Democratic Digital Services in the Data Economy. Horn, Viktoria; Draude, Claude (2024).
- SF3D: Stable Fast 3D Mesh Reconstruction with UV-unwrapping and Illumination Disentanglement. Boss, Mark; Huang, Zixuan; Vasishta, Aaryaman; Jampani, Varun (2024).
- Towards Realistic Results for Instrumentation-Based Profilers for JIT-Compiled Systems. Burchell, Humphrey; Larose, Octave; Marr, Stefan in MPLR’24 (2024).
- Casimir Effect in MEMS: Materials, Geometries, and Metrologies—A Review. Elsaka, Basma; Yang, Xiaohui; Kästner, Philipp; Dingel, Kristina; Sick, Bernhard; Lehmann, Peter; Buhmann, Stefan Yoshi; Hillmer, Hartmut (2024). 17(14) 3393.
- Through the Lens of Google CrUX: Dissecting Web Browsing Experience Across Devices and Countries. Sengupta, Jayasree; Shreedhar, Tanya; Kramer, Robert; Bajpai, Vaibhav (2024). 509–514.
- The Effect of Implicit Cues in Lane Change Situations on Driving Discomfort. Felbel, Konstantin; Dettmann, André; Bullinger, Angelika C. in Lecture Notes in Computer Science, H. Krömker (ed.) (2023). (Vol. 14049)
- Spatio-Temporal Attention Graph Neural Network for Remaining Useful Life Prediction. Huang, Zhixin; He, Yujiang; Sick, Bernhard (2023). 99–105.
- Marked Neural Spatio-Temporal Point Process Involving a Dynamic Graph Neural Network. Moallemy-Oureh, Alice; Beddar-Wiesing, Silvia; Nather, Rüdiger; Thomas, Josephine (2023). 1–7.
- FSD: A novel forged document dataset and baseline. Jaiswal, Ankit Kumar; Singh, Shiksha; Tripathy, Santosh Kumar (2023). 1–6.
- A Novel Inexpensive Camera-Based Photoelectric Barrier System for Accurate Flying Sprint Time Measurement. Uhlmann, Tom; Bräuer, Sabrina; Zaumseil, Falk; Brunnett, Guido (2023). 23(17)
- Reconstruction of incomplete X-ray diffraction pole figures of oligocrystalline materials using deep learning. Meier, David; Ragunathan, Rishan; Degener, Sebastian; Liehr, Alexander; Vollmer, Malte; Niendorf, Thomas; Sick, Bernhard (2023). 13(1) 1–12.
- The impact of bionic prostheses on users’ self-perceptions: A qualitative study. Bretschneider, Maximilian; Meyer, Bertolt; Asbrock, Frank (2023). 241 104085.
- Optimizing a superconducting radio-frequency gun using deep reinforcement learning. Meier, David; Ramirez, Luis Vera; Völker, Jens; Viefhaus, Jens; Sick, Bernhard; Hartmann, Gregor (2022). 25(10) 104604.
- A Philosophy of Software Design Osterhout, John (2021). (2nd ed.) Yaknyam Press.
- Learning Transferable Visual Models From Natural Language Supervision. Radford, Alec; Kim, Jong Wook; Hallacy, Chris; Ramesh, Aditya; Goh, Gabriel; Agarwal, Sandhini; Sastry, Girish; Askell, Amanda; Mishkin, Pamela; Clark, Jack; Krueger, Gretchen; Sutskever, Ilya (2021).
- HISTSFC: Optimization for ND Massive Spatial Points Querying. Liu, Haicheng (2020). 12(3) 07–28.
- NeRF: Representing Scenes as Neural Radiance Fields for View Synthesis. Mildenhall, Ben; Srinivasan, Pratul P.; Tancik, Matthew; Barron, Jonathan T.; Ramamoorthi, Ravi; Ng, Ren (2020).
- Annette von Droste-Hülshoff: Die Judenbuche (1842). Huszai, Villö Dorothea; Fehlmann, Ralph (2020). 112–116.
- "Mutter, lügen die Förster?". Judith Kuckarts dramatische Adaption der "Judenbuche" als Versuch über den Umgang mit Alteritäten. Morrien, Rita (2019). 12 239–253.
- Die Judenbuche. Ein Sittengemälde aus dem gebirgigten Westphalen. Korten, Lars J. G. Cornelia Blasberg (ed.) (2018). 505–529.
- Auf den Spuren der "Judenbuche". Voloj, Julian (2015). 15(3) 20–21.
- "Ein zweites Recht". Oder: Die Möglichkeiten der Fiktion. Zur fiktionstheoretischen Basis unzuverlässigen Erzählens in Annette von Droste-Hülshoffs "Judenbuche". Meixner, Sebastian R. Babel (ed.) (2014). 109–121.
- Blutlese. Annette von Droste-Hülshoffs "Die Judenbuche". Helfer, Martha (2013). 126–170.
- "Bei uns zulande auf dem Lande" und "Die Judenbuche" von Annette von Droste-Hülshoff (1797-1848). Gössmann, Wilhelm (2012). 134–135.
- "Die Judenbuche" und ihr Mörder. Kritik an einem kanonisierten Vorurteil. Heine, Marcel Thomas (2011). 8 53–63.
- "Die Judenbuche" und die Narbe des Odysseus. Zur Vorgeschichte des Realismus. Calhoon, Kenneth Scott K. S. Michael Neumann (ed.) (2011). 337–347.
- Annette von Droste-Hülshoff "Die Judenbuche". Ein Sittengemälde aus dem gebirgichten Westphalen (1842). Doering-Manteuffel, Sabine H. Z. Günter Butzer (ed.) (2010). 109–125.
- Kapitalverbrechen und familiäre Vergehen. Zur Struktur der Verdoppelung in Droste-Hülshoffs "Judenbuche". Wortmann, Thomas I. H. Claudia Liebrand (ed.) (2010). 315–337.
- Ein Spruch, der wahr sei. Hans Grimms Verarbeitung eines Motivs aus Annette von Droste-Hülshoffs "Judenbuche". Pakendorf, Gunther (2010). 38 9–22.
- Überhörtes Leid – ungeahndete Verbrechen. Annette von Droste-Hülshoffs "Die Judenbuche". Schmitz-Burgard, Sylvia (2010). 8 63–103.
- Eine Familiengeschichte in neuer Version: Die Judenbuche. Liebrand, Claudia (2008). 195–232.
- Ironie und Ethik in Annette von Droste-Hülshoffs "Judenbuche" Schaum, Konrad (2004). Winter, Heidelberg.
- "[...] ich habe Euch ein schweres Gewissen zu danken". Eine psychoanalytische Interpretation der "Judenbuche". Greve, Gisela H. E. H. Gisela Greve (ed.) (2003). 11–33.
- Annette von Droste-Hülshoff: "Die Judenbuche, 1831/42". Wittkowski, Wolfgang (2002). 167–192.
- Die Kriminalgeschichte als sozialer und religiöser Modellfall. Droste-Hülshoff, "Die Judenbuche", 1842. Borchmeyer, Dieter C. K. Klaus-Michael Bogdal (ed.) (2000). 70–73.
- Bayesian Theory Bernardo, José M.; Smith, Adrian F. M. in Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics (2000). Wiley, Chichester.
- Die Wirklichkeit des Frauenlebens: "Die Judenbuche". Yi, Mi-Seon (2000). 103–119.
- Bellersen. Das Dorf B. der "Judenbuche" von Annette von Droste-Hülshoff. Krus, Horst-Dieter (2000). 6 32–32.
- Das magische Gesetz der hebräischen Sprache. Drostes "Judenbuche" und der spätromantische Diskurs über die jüdische Magie. Kilcher, Andreas B. (1999). 118(2) 234–265.
- "Ist er kein Jude, so verdient er einer zu sein". Droste-Hülshoff’s "Die Judenbuche" and Religious Anti-Semitism. Donahue, William Collins (1999). 72(1) 44–73.
- "Was ist die Liebe?". Ein problemgeschichtliches Rätsel in der Prosa der Restaurationszeit und im Werk der Droste. Köhn, Lothar E. Ribbat (ed.) (1998). 71–93.
- Hinter den Spiegeln: Mergels Uhr und Aarons Risiko. Schmidt, Michael B. W. Johannes Heil (ed.) (1997). 171–192.
- The "Bauernhochzeit" in Droste’s "Die Judenbuche". A contemporary reading. Pickar, Gertrud Bauer L. Bodi (ed.) (1995). 68–93.
- Bayesian Theory Bernardo, José M.; Smith, Adrain F. M. in Wiley Series in Probability and Mathematical Statistics (1994). (First ) Wiley, Chichester.
- The Specter of Anti-Semitism in and around Annette von Droste-Hülshoff’s "Judenbuche". Doerr, Karin (1994). 17(3) 447–471.
- "Friedrich Mergel, geboren 1738 im Dorfe B.". Von den Namen in Annette Droste-Hülshoffs Novelle "Die Judenbuche". Rölleke, Heinz (1991). 209–216.
- Where the Devil leads: Peasant superstitions in George Sand’s "Petite fadette" and Droste-Hülshoff’s "Judenbuche". Godwin-Jones, Robert (1983). 10(1) 221–238.
- Zur Deutungsproblematik der "Judenbuche" - semiotisch gesehen. Zeller, Hans (W. Woesler, ed.) (1982). 1978-1982(5) 95–104.
- Die Judenbuche. Erläuterungen und Dokumente Droste-Hülshoff, Annette in Universal-Bibliothek, (W. Huge, ed.) (1981). Reclam, Stuttgart.
- Die Literarisierung eines Kriminalfalls. Woesler, Winfried (1980). 99 5–21.
- The Real Mystery in Droste-Hülshoff’s "Die Judenbuche". Brown, Jane K. (1978). 73(4) 835–846.
- Der Verbrecher in der deutschen Prosaliteratur des ausgehenden achtzehnten und des neunzehnten Jahrhunderts. Technical Report (PhD dissertation), Barsch, Maria Benedikta (1978).
- Die Narbe des Friedrich Mergel. Zur Aufklärung eines literarischen Motivs in Annette von Droste-Hülshoffs "Die Judenbuche". Oppermann, Gerard (1976). 50(3) 449–464.
- Kann man das Wesen gewöhnlich aus dem Namen lesen? Zur Bedeutung der Namen in der "Judenbuche" der Annette von Droste-Hülshoff. Rölleke, Heinz (1976). 70(4) 409–414.
- Annette von Droste-Hülshoff: Die Judenbuche. Freund, Winfried (1975). 63–73.
- Das Doppelgängermotiv in der Judenbuche. Murakami, Fumihiko (1975). (16) 78–86.
- Miszelle zur Judenbuche. Rölleke, Heinz (W. Woesler, ed.) (1973). 1972-1973(2) 139–140.
- Der Algerier. Der Stoff zur Novelle "Die Judenbuche" von Annette von Droste-Hülshoff, nach August von Haxthausen. Kiepke, Rudolf (1972). 22(9) 138–139.
- "Die Judenbuche" and English Literature. Thomas, L. H. C. (1969). 64(2) 351–354.
- "Die Judenbuche. Von der lebenden Gegenwärtigkeit einer "historischen" Novelle. Kleinwächter, Johannes (1963). 18–20.
- Erläuterungen zu Annette von Droste-Hülshoffs "Die Judenbuche" Woyte, Oswald in Wilhelm Königs Erläuterungen zu den Klassikern (1957). Bange, Hollfeld/Oberfranken.
- Die Vorfabel der "Judenbuche". Flaskamp, Franz (1956). 10–14.
- Bildsymbole in der deutschen Novelle. von Wiese, Benno (1955). 24(1) 131–158.
- Droste-Hülshoff, "Die Judenbuche". Silz, Walter (1954). 36–51.
- Studie zum Erzählstil der Judenbuche. Hoffmann, Lore (1950). 2 137–147.
- Ueber eine Oertlichkeit der Judenbuche von Annette Droste. Oeke, Wilhelm (1934). (121) 504–504.
- Die Örtlichkeiten in der "Judenbuche" der Annette von Droste. Oeke, Wilhelm (1927). (26)
- Vom Realismus der Droste. Antz, Joseph (1912). 25(6) 308–310.
- Der Weg zur Form. Ästhetische Abhandlungen vornehmlich zur Tragödie und Novelle Ernst, Paul (1906). Bard, Berlin.
- Eine Novelle und ihre Quellen III. Franzos, Karl Emil (1897). 61(53) 632–633.
- Der Westfälische Antiquarius. Schücking, Levin (1866). (5)
- Der Westfälische Antiquarius. Schücking, Levin (1866). (4)